Supernatural – Defending Your Life

Sam and Dean are investigating mysterious deaths.  One of which is a man that was crushed to death by a car in his apartment on the 10^th floor.  Another is a man that get chased down by a dog and then bitten to death in a diner bathroom where no customers ever saw the dog.  Turns out the first man had run a little girl over but it was ruled an accident and the second had a dog fighting operation before.  Both men were reformed.  They find some red dirt at both scenes.

They figure out that the red clay came from an abandoned apple farm.  While Sam goes to investigate, Dean goes to a bar.  Sam runs into a man being chased by something and he finds out the man just got out of prison for killing a couple when he was 18 years old.  While he was drinking he was transported to an apple farm and put on trial again by a bald man. 

After talking to Bobby they figure out that it is Osiris, the Egyptian God of the dead that is at fault.  He takes people with guilt, even if it’s small and decides if they should die or not.  So of course Bobby just says to leave since Dean is full of guilt.  Sam tries calling Dean and gets no answer and when he gets to the bar, his phone is on the ground and he’s gone.

The old man that was in prison gets left alone at the motel, with salt surrounding a chair.  But he gets scared and leaves and gets killed.

Sam goes to the Orchard and finds Osiris and Dean is tied up.  He is on trial for all the guilt he feels.  The first witness that is called is Jo Harvelle.  The second witness is Sam.  Dean is next on the stand.  Osiris says he’s guilty unless he wants to call the last witness to the stand.  Dean knows that this will be Amy (the Kitsuni that he killed last week and he hasn’t told Sam about) so he just goes with guilty.  Osiris tells him that he’ll have time to get things in order.

Sam of course calls Bobby and they figure out that Osiris can be put to sleep for a century or so by being stabbed with a ram’s horn.  So Sam figures out he can get it from the Synagogue in town.  Meanwhile Dean is surrounded by salt and Jo comes.  She feels bad because Osiris is making her kill him.  She turns the gas on the stove and is ready to ignite it when Sam stabs Osiris and Jo disappears.

At the end Dean still doesn’t tell Sam about killing Amy.